A long-simmering Republican feud has exploded into the open ahead of the North Country primary election.
Republican Assemblymember Robert Smullen is locked in a contentious primary battle with Trump-endorsed Anthony Constantino for the chance to represent New York's 21st congressional district. The June 23 contest follows Elise Stefanik's departure from the seat.
At the heart of the contest sits a private July 2021 conversation. Smullen allegedly told Stefanik he intended to primary her over redistricting concerns. He never launched the challenge and now rejects any suggestion that the discussion occurred as described.
“I’ve never planned to primary Elise Stefanik.” — Robert Smullen, New York State Assemblymember.
Smullen has also highlighted a personal bond with Stefanik during his family's darkest period. His son AJ spent time in the hospital before his death, and Smullen says Stefanik provided support throughout the ordeal and afterward.
“During the hardest time in my family’s life, Elise was there for us while my son AJ was in the hospital and after we lost him.” — Robert Smullen, New York State Assemblymember.
The New York Republican Committee endorsed Smullen in April 2026. That decision has split state party resources and messaging in the race. Constantino's Trump endorsement pulls support in the opposite direction, leaving North Country voters to navigate competing signals from party leaders.
Both candidates have spent recent months meeting voters across the rural district. Smullen has leaned on his record as an assemblymember and his long-standing ties to the region. Constantino has positioned himself as the stronger Trump-aligned choice in a district that favors conservative priorities.
The primary outcome will determine which Republican carries the party's banner in the general election for the North Country seat. With the committee's backing behind Smullen and a Trump endorsement behind Constantino, the June 23 vote will test which faction holds more sway among local Republican voters. Local observers note the contest highlights deeper tensions within the state GOP over endorsements and influence.
